by icycalm » 20 Oct 2011 09:29
Now we are getting somewhere. Here's where improvements could be made:
1. You keep moving the image for some reason. Open up two tabs on your browser and stick the gold frontpage in one and the green forum in the other and switch quickly back and forth between them: you will see that the gold background is displaced by something like 20 to 50 pixels to the right. We need them to be exactly the same size and in the same location, so that switching between the tabs produces no movement.
2. The purple in your backgrounds is still far more pronounced than in the originals. Take a look, for example, at the right side of the images: in the green ones you could not tell that there's purple at all if you don't know where to look for it, where's in the gold ones it jumps right out of the page at you. This might be due to the higher contrast between gold and purple, but you are definitely somehow brightening it up for some reason. And on the left side too. It just doesn't look good when it's that pronounced.
3. Your backgrounds are quite grainy and "pixelized". This is not so much apparent on my netbook, but on a proper monitor it is unmissable. Do that tab-switching again, both with the top image and the bottom one, and you will see how much softer the original backgrounds are. Yours are kind of soft too in the middle, perhaps, but the right and left sides (which are also the most prominent) are grainy as fuck.
4. Finally the buttons and text. The buttons need to be a little deeper in color, and the regular and hover versions a little further apart, and the text (which is the same color as in the old Insomnia: #F6F2BB) -- well, I actually I am not sure about that, but I suspect that it needs to be the same with the buttons -- either the regular or hover version, though I think it's probably the regular, so you'd have to give me the color code after you've redone those.
That's what I think needs improving. The problem is that even if you did pull off all those things successfully, it's not guaranteed that the result will be better than the green we already have... so it'd be a good idea if anyone else reading this gives us his opinion, because I've been looking at this for so long now that it's hard to see with fresh eyes. Still, it might perhaps be better if they waited until we have a sort of "final" version, so as not to become affected by our current half-attempts and whatnot.